Indianapolis's Favorite Engagement Ring Destination

At Reis-Nichols Jewelers, we offer the best engagement ring selection in the Indianapolis metro area. Our high-quality designs coupled with our wide selection of diamonds allow you to create the perfect ring. Get started by browsing below or schedule an appointment with one of our Diamond Experts ready to work with you to craft the perfect ring.

Round Cut

Marquise Cut

Emerald Cut

Oval Cut

Pear Cut

Radiant Cut

Princess Cut

Cushion Cut

Engagement Rings
Vintage Round Diamond Engagement Ring Setting
$1,035

Center Stone Sold Separately

Left Right
Half Moon 3 Stone Diamond Engagement Ring Setting
$7,705

Center Stone Sold Separately

Left Right
Baguette Halo Diamond Engagement Ring Setting
$10,995

Center Stone Sold Separately
Marquise Diamond Engagement Ring Setting
$2,250

Center Stone Sold Separately

Left Right
Three Stone Round Diamond Engagement Ring Setting
$1,530

Center Stone Sold Separately

Left Right
Complete 1.80 Carat Round Solitaire Engagement Ring
$11,105
Complete 1.18 Carat Pear Shape Engagement Ring
$6,995
Left Right
Complete 1.53 Carat Round Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring
$8,885
Left Right
Cushion Cut Halo Diamond Engagement Ring
$61,445
PRECISION SET Mod Classic Engagement Setting
$2,615

Center Stone Sold Separately

Left Right
Bypass Diamond Engagement Ring Setting
$1,500

Center Stone Sold Separately

Left Right
1.50 Carat Oval Solitaire Engagement Ring Setting
$945

Center Stone Sold Separately
Diamond Engagement Ring Setting
$2,000

Center Stone Sold Separately

Left Right
5 Stone Oval Engagement Setting
$2,970

Center Stone Sold Separately

Left Right
Complete 2.01 Oval Solitaire Engagement Ring
$16,995
Left Right
Cluster Diamond Engagement Setting with Milgrain
$970

Center Stone Sold Separately

Left Right
Vintage Style Emerald Cut Engagement Ring Setting with Side Stones
$1,530

Center Stone Sold Separately

Left Right
Pear Shape Three Stone Diamond Engagement Ring
$6,995
PRECISION SET New Aire Diamond Engagement Setting
$3,030

Center Stone Sold Separately
PRECISION SET East West Single Stone Emerald Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
$3,740
Left Right
Emerald Cut Solitaire Split Shank Engagement Ring
$9,100
PRECISION SET Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring Setting
$1,115 $1,395.00

Center Stone Sold Separately
WHITEHOUSE BROTHERS Engraved Diamond Engagement Ring Setting
$2,265 $3,775.00

Center Stone Sold Separately
PRECISION SET New Aire Petite Silk Engagement Ring Setting
$1,110 $1,390.00

Center Stone Sold Separately
PRECISION SET Mod Classic Diamond Engagement Ring
$1,960 $2,450.00

Center Stone Sold Separately
PRECISION SET New Aire Cathedral Solitaire Engagement Ring Setting
$1,565

Center Stone Sold Separately

Left Right
Complete 1.03 Carat Square Brilliant Cut Solitaire Engagement Ring
$5,950
Left Right
PRECISION SET New Aire Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring Setting
$1,235

Center Stone Sold Separately

Left Right
Split Shank Diamond Engagement Ring Setting
$3,440

Center Stone Sold Separately

Left Right
JB STAR Complete Radiant Cut Halo Diamond Engagement Ring
$129,990
Left Right
7.02 Carat Round Diamond Engagement Ring with Hidden Halo in Platinum
$140,550
Left Right
Twist Round Diamond Engagement Ring Setting
$1,365

Center Stone Sold Separately

Left Right
Complete East West Bezel Set Marquise Engagement Ring
$2,305
3/4 Carat Diamond Pave Setting
$1,335

Center Stone Sold Separately
Complete Fancy Yellow Diamond Three Stone Ring
$21,110
Left Right
Wide Marquise & Round Engagement Diamond Ring Setting
$5,995

Center Stone Sold Separately

Left Right
SINGLE STONE Cobblestone Sienna Ring
$25,000
Complete Two Stone Toi Et Moi Diamond Engagement Ring
$22,925
Complete 0.75 Carat Marquise & Pear Shape Diamond Ring
$4,335
Left Right
SETHI COUTURE Floral Rose Cut Diamond Ring
$3,080
Left Right
Diamond Accent Engagement Ring Setting
$1,425

Center Stone Sold Separately
Diamond Engagement Ring Setting
$2,100

Center Stone Sold Separately
WHITEHOUSE BROTHERS Diamond & Sapphire Engagement Ring Setting
$2,385 $3,975.00

Center Stone Sold Separately
Diamond Engagement Ring Setting
$2,370

Center Stone Sold Separately

Left Right
JB STAR Wide Emerald Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
$28,990
Oval & Round Alternating Diamond Engagement Setting
$3,445

Center Stone Sold Separately
Diamond Engagement Ring Setting
$3,090

Center Stone Sold Separately
1/3 Carat Diamond Engagement Ring Setting
$1,625

Center Stone Sold Separately
Marquise Shank Diamond Engagement Ring Setting
$3,000

Center Stone Sold Separately
Alternating Diamond Design Engagement Ring Setting
$2,100

Center Stone Sold Separately

jeweler sketching custom ring

Custom Design Your Ring

Your dream ring can become a reality in the hands of our award-winning artisans.  Our in-house jewelers work with you one one-on-one to custom design and create a ring to your specifications.

Learn More

Our Guarantees & Services

Choosing your engagement ring from our stores means a lot! Learn about our complimentary services and lifetime guarantees that come with your purchase.

Learn More

Bridal & Diamond Guide

Learn about what makes a diamond unique and how the 4 C's create a diamond's value. Also, discover your preferred style and your favorite diamond shapes.

Learn More